I have commented on the “new” female Thor on this blog a few months ago, but know it appears that last week’s Thor #5 hit a raw nerve with the fanbase. The long and short of it was that Thor scribe, Jason Aaron, used Crusher Creel (AKA the Absorbing Man) as the mouthpiece for skeptical fans that questioned why this particular woman was worthy to wield Mjolnir. He used “feminism ruins everything” as loaded phrase that was a thinly veiled accusation of misogyny. However, I already brought of the point that placing Mjolnir in the hands or the outright (temporary) replacement of any hero with another, particularly with a visible minority, is a tired cliché. After reading the pages in question I have come to a conclusion.
Lady Thor is not a character. Rather, she serves as an ideological mouthpiece bereft of any identifying characteristics. Her worthiness to wield Mjolnir is an informed attribute that violates the old axiom of “Show, don’t tell” and is a telltale sign of sloppy writing. It also particularly egregious when there are other Asgardian women who are capable warriors in their own right like Lady Sif and Valkyrie and both are fairly prominent in the Thor mythos and the Marvel universe in general. It is essentially an admission that Marvel has no faith in the character outside of briefly bumping up sales.
Speaking of which, compare the case of Lady Thor to the new Ms. Marvel AKA Kamala Khan, who received considerable promotion by Marvel and the mainstream press. While I have not been able to pick up Ms. Marvel, but I have glanced through the tale on my intermittent trips to the comic shop so see what she is about. Kamala Khan is a character with her own distinct characteristics; yes, Marvel heavily publicized her Muslim identity but she is more than the sum her parts. One quote from Ms. Marvel scribe, G. Willow Wilson, resonates with me.
“She’s very much the kind of girl who grew up staring wistfully at Manhattan, thinking ‘If only I could make it to the big city.’ Jersey City is not just the backdrop of the series, but very much a part of Kamala’s own journey.”
The operative word here is “journey” where Kamala is supposed to grow as a character and form her own identity as an individual. Her wish of making “it” in the big city makes her a sympathetic character, not just Muslims and young girls, but also anyone who dreams of becoming more than what they are.
Kamala’s idol, Carol Danvers also experienced growth as a character that culminated in her taking the mantle of Captain Marvel, having “began” life as a supporting character for Mar-Vell. Immortus manipulated and raped her; Rogue stole her powers and her memories; and she struggled with alcoholism but came out of those experiences a confident and stronger heroine. If I could equate one Marvel character to Wonder Woman, it would Carol Danvers, or rather Captain Marvel. Granted, given that she attained the rank of colonel with the USAF, referring to her as “captain” sounds like a demotion.
But I digress.
Heroes must undergo their own crucibles and struggles. However, I see no such struggle Lady Thor, she simply lifted Mjolnir without so much as a demonstration of her worthiness and appropriated the name. The fact that Marvel has concealed her identity has to the hollowness of the character and the revelation of her identity will be disservice to women in comics because either her creation was an ideological means to an end, or Marvel stripped an existing character of her identity in the name of “girl power.” Some like Ben Kuchera of Polygon praise this ham-fisted approach, but the fact of the matter that people of his mindset do not see women as people. They see women and other minorities as tools to further their own agenda and will deny the very existence of minorities that have the audacity to question their narrative.
How people decide to spend their money is none of my business. However, the events of Thor #5 confirm my fears for the (non) character and affirm my decision not to sink my money into another cynical attempt to temporarily increase sales. Such sloppy storytelling ultimately shows that Mr. Aaron and Marvel do not see women as characters, just other soundbox for their regressive values. Perhaps the bigger sin here is that Lady Thor diverts attention from worthier titles like the Ms. Marvel and Captain Marvel titles.